The trouble spot on this job is almost always the torsion hardware itself, not the spring alone. On houses from the late 80s and 90s, you'll often find the original drums, shafts, and center bearing still installed, and a replacement spring put on mismatched or undersized hardware doesn't hold tension right - it just fails again, usually within a year. We see this a lot on doors that had a "quick fix" spring swap done at some point without anyone checking the shaft and bearing underneath it.
Across the roughly 24,582 owner-occupied houses in this service area, a lot of garages are also storage space, workshop space, or parking for a second vehicle that gets used daily - which means the door cycles more than the minimum and hardware wear shows up sooner than the spring's rated life alone would suggest.
Honest limitation: if the torsion tube, drums, or bottom brackets are rusted or bent on a door this old, we're not going to patch around it. Replacing a spring on compromised hardware is a short-term fix that costs you a second service call later, and we'll tell you that up front instead of billing you twice.